The pies

18 inch pies, cooked well done.

Every pie on the Robby’s Pizza menu in Ridgewood, NJ, and what is on it. Prices match our online ordering.

3 MIN READ

A Robby's Pizza pepperoni pie, cooked well done

The menu.

Cheese

$23

San Marzano tomatoes, Grande mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil, basil and hand grated Asiago.

Try a regular cheese first. It is the best way to tell how good a pizza is.

Robby’s Pizza pepperoni pie

Pepperoni

$28

San Marzano tomatoes, Grande mozzarella, cup and char pepperoni, basil, extra virgin olive oil and Asiago.

Online: cheese pie, add pepperoni

Hot honey roni

$28

San Marzano tomatoes, Grande mozzarella, cup and char pepperoni, Mike’s Hot Honey, basil, olive oil and Asiago.

Vodka stracciatella

$29

Vodka sauce, Grande mozzarella, creamy stracciatella, basil, extra virgin olive oil and Asiago.

Robby’s Pizza meatball stracciatella pie

Meatball stracciatella

$32

San Marzano tomatoes, Grande mozzarella, meatballs, creamy stracciatella, basil, extra virgin olive oil and Asiago.

Tie dye

$28

Grande mozzarella, San Marzano tomatoes, vodka sauce, pesto drizzle, basil, extra virgin olive oil and Asiago.

Robby’s Pizza truffle mushroom pie

Truffle mushroom

$28

Crème fraîche, Grande mozzarella, roasted shiitake mushrooms, truffle oil, basil and Asiago.

Robby’s Pizza margherita pie

Margherita

$25

San Marzano tomatoes, fresh fior di latte mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil, basil and hand grated Asiago.

Robby’s Pizza tomato pie

Tomato pie

$23

San Marzano tomatoes, Pecorino Romano, extra virgin olive oil, basil and hand grated Asiago.

Robby’s Pizza white pie

White pie

$28

Sesame seed crust, crème fraîche, Grande mozzarella, chives, extra virgin olive oil and Asiago.

Meatballs Two per order$11
Calzone$14

Ordering online? Tap the 18 inch pizza, pick your pie from the list, then add toppings to the whole pie or just one half. You can ask for a double cut there too.

How Rob bakes them.

Well done

Every pie comes out of the oven with a charred crust and bottom. That is the crunch.

Light on cheese

Too much cheese and a pie goes soft, so Rob keeps it lighter on purpose.

Asiago on top

Freshly grated Asiago goes over the hot pie, right before it gets cut.

“If you end up putting a ton of cheese on a pizza, it’s definitely going to affect the crispiness of the pizza.”

Rob, owner of Robby’s Pizza

The sauce test.

Before opening, Rob lined up three tomatoes and tasted them straight, side by side. A California tomato, an organic California tomato and an Italian tomato.

CaliforniaTASTED
Organic CaliforniaTASTED
ItalianWINNER

The tomatoes are milled by hand and the sauce gets one more thing, sea salt.

“Tomatoes and sea salt. That’s it.”

Rob

Start with a cheese.

A plain cheese pie is the best way to tell how good a pizza is. Rob won’t call his the best, though.

“I never say I’m the best. Everyone has different tastes.”

Rob

No pineapple here.

It is not on the menu and it is not coming. Rob says it is nothing personal.

“Business decision.”

Rob

Pick your pie.

Order online for pickup or walk in at 102 N Maple Ave in Ridgewood, NJ.