The dough
Three day sourdough.
From the starter to the oven. Every Robby’s Pizza pie starts in the cellar at 102 N Maple Ave in Ridgewood, NJ, with no yeast, two flours and three days in the fridge.
No yeast. On purpose.
Most pizza dough rises with commercial yeast. Robby’s Pizza dough doesn’t use any. It rises on a sourdough starter, a living mix of flour and water that Rob feeds every single day.
“We use a sourdough starter and that’s what makes it rise.”
Rob, owner of Robby’s Pizza
Ask Rob why he went sourdough and he’ll tell you it’s easier to digest. Then he’ll get to the real reason.
“Most importantly, the flavor.”
Rob
The starter never takes a day off.
Every day part of the starter gets thrown out and the rest gets fresh flour and water. That is how a sourdough starter stays alive, and it never stops.
“Keep doing it every day, literally, for the rest of your life.”
Rob
One batch of starter makes two batches of dough, about 120 pies. Left alone overnight it doubles in size. Just flour and water, nothing else.

Two flours, four ingredients.

The flour
Caputo Americano, an unbleached Italian flour with no bromate, mixed with an organic whole wheat flour from Central Milling in Utah.
That’s the whole list. No seed oils anywhere.
- FlourCaputo and organic whole wheat
- Water
- Sea salt
- Olive oilExtra virgin
Then it waits three days.
HRS IN THE FRIDGE
Robby’s Pizza dough cold ferments for 72 hours before it is ever stretched. Here is the whole run, from the mixer to the oven.
- MixEvery batch is weighed out exactly, so every day comes out the same.
- Rest 6 hoursThe dough goes into three big bins and bulk ferments for six hours.
- Ball itThen it gets divided and balled up, one dough ball per pie.
- Fridge 3 daysThe dough balls cold ferment in the fridge for three full days.
- Bake well doneStretched by hand, topped light and baked with a charred crust and bottom.
Rob writes everything down.
Before a batch gets mixed, Rob logs the air temperature, the temperature of the flour and the pH of the water. If a batch ever comes out wrong, he can look back and see what changed.
“All of those batches are precisely weighed. So everything’s exactly the same every day.”
Rob
DOUGH LOG
- Air templogged
- Flour temp71.3
- Water pHlogged
we track everything
Why the hours say till sold out.
Every dough needs its three days in the fridge before it becomes a pie, so the dough for today was made days ago. Rob plans on pizza all day, and that is why the hours read 12pm to 8pm or till sold out.
Taste the three days.
Order online for pickup or walk in at 102 N Maple Ave in Ridgewood, NJ.